Arch Cochran was not an easy man to admire. The records are thorough about him, and almost none of what they record is to his credit. This chronicle sets him down as the records show him, because a family history that keeps only the flattering people is not a history. It is a scrapbook.
He was born in June 1869 in the Illinois District of the Cherokee Nation. His father was Avery “Ave” Cochran, a son of Moses Cochran. Avery served in the Civil War with Company I of the Third Indian Home Guard, one of the Union regiments raised from the Cherokee and neighboring tribes. He came home from that war and died in March 1873, when Arch was not yet four. Arch’s mother was Nancy Ballard, whose Cherokee name was Nunce. Her father was Alexander Ballard, whose Cherokee name was Judy; her mother was Catherine Swimmer, whose Cherokee name was Ca-haw-kee, the White Catcher. Nancy outlived two husbands and most of the trouble her son caused.
He claimed his Cherokee blood plainly. When the Dawes Commission asked in 1901 how much he carried, he answered, “About 1/4 I guess,” and he traced the line through his mother, through the Ballard and Swimmer families of the Illinois and Saline Districts. The only “white” in his enrollment papers was never his own. It was the intermarriage status of his third wife, Mae, a white woman enrolled as a Cherokee by her marriage to him. Arch was Cherokee by blood and said so under oath every time he was asked.
The Wives, and the Order of Things
◆ ◆ ◆Arch fathered children by three women. Only the last of the three is a documented legal marriage, and the first two relationships overlapped in the same years, which tells you something about how he kept house.
The first was Lucy NoWife, three-quarters Cherokee, daughter of Andy NoWife of the Tahlequah District and Dina Sanders of the Illinois District. Whether Arch and Lucy were ever legally married is not established in the records I have. They had two children: Margaret Ellen “Maggie,” born March 4, 1889, and George Walter “Buck,” born January 4, 1894. Lucy later married a man named Stevens and carried her own Dawes card, field number 6640. Her two children by Arch held Cherokee allotments under their own names.
Running through those same years was Mary Campbell, a native Cherokee, daughter of David Campbell, whose Cherokee name was Tsi-lo-nv-tsi, and Cherokee Griffin, listed on the 1880 authenticated roll, Illinois District, page 517, number 425. By her, Arch had three more children: Elizabeth “Lizzie” in 1890, Mallie in 1892, and Carrie in 1893. For a long time I took Arch and Mary for husband and wife. The 1912 court record corrects that. Asked under cross-examination whether he had ever been legally married to the mother of these children, Arch answered, “No.” So across the span from 1889 to 1894, two women were bearing Arch Cochran’s children, and the records confirm a marriage to neither.
Mary Campbell died in 1894, about twenty-six years old. On the second day of November, 1895, roughly a year later, Arch married Mary Etta “Mae” Miller, a white woman, daughter of Henry and Caroline Miller. That one was a marriage by the book. Mae enrolled as a Cherokee by intermarriage and testified to the date herself in 1902. By Mae, Arch had a second large set of children: Joseph Lloyd in 1896, then Zell, Edwin Levi, Ora May, Bessie Ella, and Eliza Jo “Jo T.” The one woman he married formally was the one woman of the three who was not Cherokee.
Maggie and George by Lucy. Lizzie, Mallie, and Carrie by Mary. Half a dozen by Mae. That was the household, or rather the households.
The Children He Gave Away
◆ ◆ ◆When Mary Campbell was dying in 1894 or 1895, she did not leave her three little girls to Arch. She gave them to his mother. The application Thomas J. Pettit filed as their guardian states it directly: the children “were given to Nancy Pettit by their Mother Mary Cochran on her death bed and have been in their care and custody ever since.” Nancy Ballard had by then married Thomas Pettit, and it was the Pettits, not Arch, who raised Lizzie, Mallie, and Carrie. The 1912 newspaper says of Carrie that she “had never been a member of his family. She had been raised by Tom Pettitt from infancy.” Arch confirmed it himself on the stand: asked if he had always lived at Tom Pettit’s, meaning the children, he said, “Yes sir.” Asked if he ever had the care of Carrie, he said, “No sir.”
A dying mother handing her daughters to the grandmother rather than the father tells you what she thought of the father. The record does not editorialize. It does not need to.
The Oil, and Where It Went
◆ ◆ ◆Here is where Arch becomes more than a man who shirked his children. He came back for them when they were worth something.
The girls and the younger children held Cherokee allotments, and some of that land fell in the oil belt around Cookson. After a contest over the selections, the lands were secured for the minors. Arch had himself made guardian of his children, and as guardian he collected their oil royalties, paid directly from the pipeline company, in sums the 1912 paper put in the thousands. (The exact figures are garbled in the scan and I want the clean image before I quote dollars.)
What he did with the money is documented. He left home. He took up residence in Muskogee, bought automobiles, leased a rooming house called the St. George, and put the children’s funds into Muskogee real estate in the West Park Addition near Agency Hill. His first attorney withdrew from the case rather than file an accounting that, in the paper’s words, “appeared on its face to be padded.” Part of what made it padded: a bill of nineteen hundred dollars for the care of the three children, charged while Carrie was living, as she always had, with Tom Pettit.
It was Mae, his own wife, who stopped him. In January 1911, pregnant, she went before the County Court and filed for a citation requiring Arch to account, because she believed he was squandering the children’s money. When he failed, repeatedly, to file a report or post additional bond, the court removed him as guardian. The man lost custody of his children’s fortune at the request of the woman he was married to. I find I do not have much to add to that.
Carrie, and Arkansas
◆ ◆ ◆There is one more episode, and I want to be careful with it because I do not yet have the article in my hand.
I have been told, and the 1912 Tahlequah Herald appears to allude to it, that Arch took his daughter Carrie out of Indian Territory and into Arkansas, and kept her there until she signed her land over to him. The Herald breaks off mid-sentence about Arch having “took Carrie sometime during the year” and left “the country.” The motive fits everything else on this page: Carrie’s allotment was oil land, and a deed signed in Arkansas spends the same as a deed signed at home. I am still looking for the full account. When I find it, it goes here, with a citation. For now I record it as family report and a strong lead, not as proven fact. I am telling you what I have been told and what the record gestures at. I am not telling you more than that.
The Long Drift
◆ ◆ ◆After the court took the guardianship from him, Arch stayed on in Muskogee for a time. A 1913 suit there, the First National Bank against Woods and Arch Cochran, still has him owning about fifty head of cattle branded L.V. near Cookson, so he had not gone entirely to ruin. Where he went in the years after that, the records do not yet follow him cleanly. He surfaces again only at the end.
The Lamb and the Dove
◆ ◆ ◆Arch died on November 20, 1931, at the Indian Hospital in Claremore, age sixty-two. His obituary is short and worth reading slowly.
Arch Cochran, born at Tahlequah, Okla., and died at the Indian hospital, Claremore, Nov. 20, at the age of 62 years. He leaves to mourn his death two daughters, Mrs. Rollans, of Tulsa, and Mrs. Robinson of Pawhuska, and one brother, of Pawhuska.
It names two daughters as survivors, and one brother. The three girls Mary Campbell left to the Pettits, Lizzie, Mallie, and Carrie, are not among them. Which two daughters were named I am still working out; they were most likely from his later families. What the notice records, without meaning to, is how far Arch had scattered his own children. Of all of them, only two daughters and one brother stood close enough to be named.
ARCH COCHRAN GA · 1869
NOV · 1931Carved with a dove and a lamb.
His tombstone reads “ARCH COCHRAN, GA 1869, NOV 1931.” It was carved with a dove and a lamb, the dove for peace and the lamb for innocence. I have looked at a good many headstones in this work, and that is the one that stopped me. A man who took his children’s oil money, padded his bills, and carried his daughter across a state line to pry her land loose, lying now under the two gentlest images a stonecutter keeps in stock. I did not arrange that irony. I only found it.
There is one more thing, and it is the only piece of him that is not on paper. A relative told me that Arch was so tall and so big that when he died his casket would not fit through the door of the house, and they had to lay him out on the porch for the wake. It is oral tradition, not yet documented, and I keep it because it is the kind of thing the records never preserve and the family never forgets. The last image we have of Arch Cochran is of a man too large to bring back inside.